Before We Blame the Budget, Let’s Look at the Why

You know those nights when you’ve just had enough?

You’ve been going all day.

You’re tired.

Your brain is tired.

Your patience is tired.

You go grocery shopping, and all you can think about is getting home.

You unload the groceries.

You put some of them away.

And then you order a pizza.

Wait.

Didn’t we just go grocery shopping?

Yes.

Yes, we did.

There is literally food in the refrigerator.

But we don’t care.

Because tonight, we’re done.

We don’t want to cook.

We don’t want to think about what to cook.

We don’t want another decision.

We just want someone to bring us a pizza.

So we order it.

And maybe a little treat to go with it.

Then we sit down on the couch.

Finally.

We can relax.

We turn on the television and start scrolling through the streaming services.

Netflix.

Hulu.

Amazon Prime.

Disney+.

Whatever else we’re paying for this month.

And somehow, after scrolling through all of them, we decide there is absolutely nothing to watch.

So what do we do?

We pay $20 for a movie.

A movie we could have probably watched on one of the four streaming services we’re already paying for if we’d had the patience to look long enough.

But we don’t.

Because tonight isn’t really about the movie.

And it probably wasn’t really about the pizza either.

See, sometimes we’re not spending money because we want something.

We’re spending money because we want to feel something different. Or feel nothing at all.

We want the day to be over.

We want our brain to shut up for a minute.

We want to be taken care of.

We want something easy.

We want comfort.

We want a reward for making it through the day.

And sometimes spending money is the quickest way we know how to get there.

That’s the part of our spending that can be really hard to see.

Because when we look at the bank account, all we see is:

Pizza.

Treat.

Movie.

$20 here.

$15 there.

And we think:

“Why am I always spending so much money?”

But maybe a better question is:

“What was I really looking for when I spent that money?”

One of my clients had a moment like this recently.

She had gone grocery shopping.

She had food in the house.

And then she ordered pizza.

Then she bought another treat.

Then she got home, sat on the couch and spent $20 on a movie even though she already had multiple streaming services.

And instead of just brushing it off, she stopped.

She looked at what she’d done.

And she asked herself:

“Why did I do that?”

That question was the breakthrough because she finally became curious about her own behavior.

Instead of saying:

“I shouldn’t have done that.”

She asked:

“Why did I?”

That’s a very different question.

How often do we do things with our money without really knowing why?

We buy something because we’re stressed.

We order dinner because we’re exhausted.

We go shopping because we’re bored.

We buy something new because we need a little excitement.

We treat ourselves because we’ve had a hard week.

We spend because we feel like we deserve something.

We buy something because everyone else seems to have it.

We shop when we’re lonely.

We spend when we’re celebrating.

We spend when we’re sad.

We spend when we’re angry.

Heck, sometimes we spend when we’re just having a Tuesday.

And most of the time, we don’t stop to ask ourselves what’s really happening.

We just swipe.

Click.

Order.

Done.

Until the credit card bill shows up.

And then we’re staring at the statement wondering how we managed to spend that much money.

But one thing I do know; our spending usually makes sense to us in the moment.

That’s why telling ourselves, “I just need to stop spending so much” doesn’t always work.

Because in the moment, the spending is solving something.

Maybe not a financial problem.

An emotional one.

The pizza solves the problem of being too tired to cook.

The shopping trip solves the problem of boredom.

The new purse gives us a little excitement.

The Amazon package gives us something to look forward to.

The $20 movie gives us two hours where we don’t have to think about the day we just had or some other situation we’re dealing with.

And for a little while…it works.

That’s what makes it so easy to repeat.

But what happens when the feeling wears off?

The pizza is gone.

The treat is gone.

The movie ends.

The package arrives.

The excitement fades.

And we’re left with the same stress.

The same exhaustion.

The same loneliness.

The same problems.

Except now we’ve spent money too.

And that’s when we start beating ourselves up.

“I have got to get better with money.”

“I don’t know why I do this.”

“I need more discipline.”

“I can’t seem to stick to a budget.”

Maybe.

But maybe we need to look a little deeper.

Because if we’re using money to make ourselves feel better, then the problem isn’t simply that we’re spending too much.

We’re asking our money to do a job it was never designed to do.

Money can buy comfort.

But it can’t create peace.

It can buy dinner.

But it can’t fix exhaustion.

It can buy something beautiful.

But it can’t fix insecurity.

It can buy entertainment.

But it can’t make us happy when we’re unhappy with our lives.

It can give us a temporary escape.

But eventually, we have to come back.

And sometimes that little escape costs us a lot more than we realize.

Not just financially.

So what if we stopped judging ourselves long enough to get curious?

The next time we find ourselves making one of those purchases that makes us think, “Why did I buy that?”, let’s pause.

Not to shame ourselves.

Just to notice.

Ask:

What was I feeling right before I bought it?

Was I tired?

Stressed?

Bored?

Lonely?

Overwhelmed?

Was I looking for a reward?

Was I trying to escape my day?

Was I trying to make myself feel better?

Was I trying to fill some empty space?

And then ask:

What did I expect this purchase to do for me?

That’s the question I really want us to start asking.

Because sometimes the answer has very little to do with the thing we’re buying.

And maybe that’s where our financial breakthrough starts.

Not with another budget.

Not with cutting every little pleasure out of our lives.

Not with deciding we’re never ordering pizza again.

Because let’s be honest. Sometimes we just want pizza.

And I’m not taking that away from anybody.

The goal isn’t to make ourselves miserable in the name of financial responsibility.

The goal is to understand ourselves well enough that we are making the decision instead of the emotion making it for us.

There’s a difference between:

“I don’t feel like cooking tonight, and I have room in my budget, so I’m ordering pizza.”

and:

“I’ve had a horrible day and I don’t want to deal with anything else, so I’m ordering pizza, a treat, and a $20 movie because I just want to check out for a while.”

From the outside, those purchases look almost identical.

But they’re not. One is a choice. The other is a coping mechanism.

And if we don’t recognize the difference, we can spend a whole lot of money trying to feel better.

That $20 movie might have been the best $20 my client ever spent.

Not because the movie was great.

She doesn’t even remember much about it.

But because it made her stop. It made her notice. It made her ask the question.

“Why did I do that?”

And once we start asking ourselves that question without judgment, we start seeing things differently.

We begin to notice our patterns.

We notice what triggers our spending.

We notice the stories we tell ourselves.

We notice when we’re using money as a reward.

We notice when we’re using it as an escape.

We notice when we’re buying something because we genuinely want it…

and when we’re buying something because we desperately want to feel different.

And that awareness is powerful.

Because we can’t change what we refuse to look at.

So tonight, if you find yourself standing in the kitchen staring at a full refrigerator while opening the food delivery app…

I’m not going to tell you not to order the pizza.

I’m just going to ask you to pause for a second.

Take a breath.

And ask yourself:

“What do I really need right now?”

Maybe the answer is pizza.

And that’s okay.

But maybe it’s rest.

Maybe it’s comfort.

Maybe it’s a break.

Maybe it’s connection.

Maybe it’s permission to admit that you’re exhausted.

And if you can figure out what you really need, you might discover that sometimes the thing we’re trying to buy isn’t actually what we’re looking for.

And that realization can change more than our spending.

It can change our relationship with money.

And maybe even our relationship with ourselves.